The Greedy Capitalist: David Veksler's Homepage :: Archives :: Sun_microsystems_is_a_hypocrite

What lies behind us and lies before us are small matters compared to what lies within us.-- Ralph Waldo Emerson

August 23, 2003

Sun Microsystems is a Hypocrite

I've spent the last two days installing and playing with Windows Server 2003. It ads some much-needed features and improvements to IIS that make it a much better server OS than the Windows 2000 line. Aside from some unnecessary hardware and software compatibility issues, I have one complaint: it’s missing Microsoft’s own optimized version of Java. Is this a case of Microsoft trying to "bully" Sun? No, the missing Java is a result of a Sun lawsuit intended to force Microsoft to scuttle its superior version of Java in lieu of Sun's because Microsoft’s implementation is "incompatible" and “obsolete.” My own experience with both versions indicates that Microsoft’s Java is better, faster, and just as compatible as Sun’s.

In the latest decision, the judge ruled that by producing a better version of Sun’s “open” standard, Microsoft was using its monopoly power to help its .Net platform. Apparently, making your competitor's product (which MS had a license to) work better is "anti-competitive." To his credit, he ruled that (for now) Microsoft does not have to include Sun’s inferior Java in Microsoft’s own operating systems.

Why is a company supposedly dedicated to innovation and open standards preventing others from making their own improved versions? How can Sun criticize Microsoft for being “monopolistic” while trying to force its Java into Windows and engaging in the same deals with computer manufacturers as Microsoft to bundle Java onto desktops? There are many complex licensing and technical issues here, but it is clear to me that Sun has realized that its client and server-side Java products are inferior to .Net and (like SCO) is trying to win in the courts where it has failed in innovation.

Posted by David at August 23, 2003 02:23 AM | TrackBack

Comments

Post a comment

Interact:

Forum
Chat Room
Listserv
Contact Me

Top Shelf:

Friends:
Absolute Reason
The Economistress
The Rational Egoist

Objectivist Bloggers:
Alexander Marriott's Wit and Wisdom
EGO
About the War
Fredrik Norman
wickens.ca
Nous Poetikos
Venting Steam
Chris Davis

Bloggin' Intellectuals:
The Agitator
VodkaPundit
The Patriette
Commiewatch
Free North Korea!
Little Green Footballs
Eye On The Left
Future of Russia
Free Will
Tim Blair
::Freespace::
InstaPundit
Hootinan

Organizations:
The Center for the Advancement of Capitalism
The Rule of Reason
ObjectivismOnline.net
Aggie Objectivism Club
Ayn Rand Institute
GMU Objectivist Club Blog
Utah Objectivist Club Blog
Geeks With Guns
Free Republic

E-Zines:
Capitalism Magazine
RightWingNews
The Intellectual Activist
The American Individualist
Drudge Report

Techies:
TechCentralStation
.Net Weblogs
Dive Into Mark
kottke.org
Scriptygoddess
Scripting News
C:/Pirillo
GeekPress
The War on SPAM
Textism

Humor:
Cox and Forkum
Baloo
Fillibuster Cartoons
DaveBarry
Dave's Columns
ScrapleFace
Allah is in Da House
Penny Arcade

Miscellaneous:
Quent Cordair: Artist's Studio & Gallery News
My Favorite Art
Everything in Moderation
Sekimori Live Blog

« LibertyLoggers »
Blogroll Me!

Calendar:

Archives: