[admin]

Secrecy is the beginning of tyranny.-- Robert Heinlein

October 06, 2002

Disney Socialism

I just finished watching the 1998 Disney movie "A Bug Life" and despite my hopes to the contrary, I was reminded how pervasive socialist ideology has become in absolutely everything Disney produces. I have come to expect collectivist overtones from Disney's regular programming, but the extent to which its animated films are full of socialist indoctrination is simply disgusting. Unlike most liberal media companies, Disney produces more than the usual "multicultural" garbage but actually inserts Marxist ideology into the plot of its animated children's movies.



"A Bugs Life" has all the elements of the topical Disney presentation of the class struggle: the proletariat, represented by the worker ants, the bourgeoisie, represented by the grasshoppers, the greedy slave-driving boss, represented by the "boss flea" in charge of the flee circus. Famous lines include [as I remember them]: "if the ants only realized that they outnumber us a hundred to one, we would be finished!" and "you've committed the ultimate sin: you put yourself before the colony!" If that were not enough, the flea-boss frequently explains "let's go, there's money to be made!" as he denies his worker's request for a raise and proposes a routine where one the bugs is burnt to a crisp. Meanwhile, the movie makes it a point to show the ant-queen diligently joining the worker ants in their work, as she and Flik, the hero repeatedly explain "I care for the colony!" I'd like to say that Flik is at least a creative non-conformist, but the movie makes a point to show that none of his ideas are self-inspired, and all of them come to fruition only by collective effort.



Not surprisingly, the movie ends with the defeat of the overclass, as the revolutionary hero Flik inspires the ants to rise up and ensure that the ants get to keep all the "surplus" grain they collect by their collective effort. Compare this plot to "Antz," a Dreamworks SKG release, which featured an ant who questioned his role in the ant collective and championed individualism and private ingenuity.



This review may be four years late, but Disney has clearly continued its tradition of promoting Marxist ideology in movies such as "Monster's Inc." where the villain is a factory owner who is found torturing little children (Can those capitalist pigs get any worse??) and is replaced by one of the factory workers by a .government agency. In general, everything Disney touches display several common elements: the subjugation of the individual to the collective, the rejection of all selfish motivations as immoral, the worship of authority figures, the proposition that all cultures and values (other than capitalism) are equivalent, and of course, the duality between the greedy capitalist slave-drivers, and the hardworking workers of the collective, who almost always rise up and show the evil capitalists who's boss.


I'd point out some other examples of Disney socialism, but I do my very best not to support Disney in any way, and if you care about self-interest, and freedom, I strongly suggest you do the same.

Posted by David at October 6, 2002 05:11 AM | TrackBack
Comments

I was surprised by your Ayn Rand-like analysis. Certainly history shows Walt Disney was not on the socialist barricades.

Are you saying Disney changed its capitalist philosophy under Eisner & Katzenberg?

Brian Sieben

Posted by: Brian Sieben at October 20, 2003 05:40 AM

I've heard that Walt Disney himself was an advocate of a number of socialist policies such as the income tax, and made propaganda movies advocating them around WWII, thought I've been unable to find evidence of this.

As a disclaimer, I admit that I get too hung up on ideology sometimes, and miss the wider sense-of-life theme a movie might have. The heroic characters, bright environments and happy endings of animated Disney movies overshow the horrible underlying ideologies some of them have.

For more, read this.

Posted by: David at December 14, 2003 03:55 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






Interact:

Forum
Chat Room
Listserv
Contact Me

Top Shelf:

Friends:
Absolute Reason
The Economistress
The Rational Egoist

Bloggin' Intellectuals:
The Agitator
VodkaPundit
The Patriette
Commiewatch
Free North Korea!
Eye On The Left
Future of Russia
Free Will
Tim Blair
::Freespace::
InstaPundit

Objectivist Bloggers:

Little Green Footballs
Alexander Marriott's Wit and Wisdom
EGO
About the War
Fredrik Norman
wickens.ca
NoumenalSelf
Hootinan
Nous Poetikos
Venting Steam

Organizations:
The Center for the Advancement of Capitalism
The Rule of Reason
ObjectivismOnline.net
Aggie Objectivism Club
Ayn Rand Institute
GMU Objectivist Club Blog
Utah Objectivist Club Blog
Geeks With Guns
Free Republic


E-Zines:
Capitalism Magazine
RightWingNews
The Intellectual Activist
The American Individualist
Drudge Report

Techies:

TechCentralStation
.Net Weblogs
Dive Into Mark
kottke.org
Scriptygoddess
Scripting News
C:/Pirillo
GeekPress
The War on SPAM
Textism

Humor:

Cox and Forkum
Baloo
Fillibuster Cartoons
DaveBarry
Dave's Columns
ScrapleFace
Allah is in Da House
Penny Arcade

Miscellaneous:
My Favorite Art
Everything in Moderation
Sekimori Live Blog

« LibertyLoggers »
Blogroll Me!

Calendar:
February 2004
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29            
Archives:
Search


Recent Entries:

Categories:

s: %28311%2Dlove song mp3...
s: Low Murderer.mp3
dpxml.webcrawler.com/info...
s: uncut penis photo
blo.gs/ping.php
s: Mendelssohn rondo mp3
s: Herm Albright
s88515748.onlinehome.us/g...
s: "311 - Love Song.mp3"
s: "311 - Love Song.mp3"
s: free nude paris hilton
s: graph of top economic ...
s: paris hilton sex tape
s: graph of top economic ...
dpxml.webcrawler.com/info...
popdex.com/
s: Ride of the Valkyrie m...
s: howard roark
s: frank greedy
s: Ride of the Valkyrie m...

Self-Defense: A Human Right

The Truth About Israel

Subscribe to my blog!




Random Blog:
About Me | Blog | Essays | Photo Album | Resume | Webcam | Favorites | Projects | Contact |